November 17, 2026

If I used AI for donor emails, this is what I'd do first

Thank you for reading this. I know your week is already full, so I will keep it short.

A Vice President of Development at a Texas nonprofit told me she was rewriting everything her AI gave her. She was not a beginner. She had already built her own custom versions of ChatGPT, and it still did not sound like her.

Then she told me why. She writes to a major donor one way, to her board another way, and to her colleagues a third way. Her AI had learned an average of all three, so it sounded like none of them.

Your nonprofit works the same way. It has one voice, and that voice changes a little for donors, for your board and for volunteers. So before I ask AI for a single donor email, I teach it how my team writes. Here are the four steps I use.

Step 1. Find three emails

Pick three emails your nonprofit has already sent. Choose ones you were proud of.

  • One that asked for money
  • One that thanked a donor
  • One to your board or your volunteers

Three different kinds matter, because that is how your AI learns how your writing changes for each reader.

Before you paste them anywhere, take out private details. Remove donor names, home addresses, phone numbers and any gift tied to a real person. Use a made-up first name like “Jordan” in their place.

Step 2. Run one prompt

Open a new chat in ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. Paste your three emails and ask the AI to write a set of writing rules for your nonprofit.

Ask for rules a stranger could follow. “Warm” and “professional” are not rules. “No sentence over 20 words” is a rule.

The full prompt is in my free guide, and you can copy it from there.

Step 3. Save it where your AI can find it

Save the writing rules inside your AI tool, so every new chat starts from them. The guide shows where to save them in ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini.

If you have no time for that today, keep the rules in a note on your phone. Paste them at the top of any chat. It is less tidy, but it works right away.

Step 4. Test it

Ask for something you write every week. For example:

Using our writing rules, write a thank-you email to Marcus, who gave $50 for the first time on Giving Tuesday.

Then ask for the same news, written for your board. If the two sound the same, add one clear rule for each reader.

Where AI gets this wrong

Always read the numbers. In one of my tests, the AI wrote that $50 “can provide food for one person for a week”. The nonprofit had never said that, so the AI made it up.

Give the AI your facts, and check every number against your own records before you send. No set of writing rules replaces your judgment or what you know about your donor.

Get the free guide

The guide is called Teach AI to Write Like Your Nonprofit. It is free, and it has the full prompt and the saving steps for all three tools.

Get the free guide

If you use Claude, the video on this page is lesson 1 of my free course. It is four minutes long.

Ankush

All posts